Bringing families together since 1976

Patio carryout available

Prices Subject To Change

Italian-American comfort eats presented in an informal space with wine, beer & outdoor seating.

Papa Nick's now featuring
Deep Dish Pizza !

Best Specialty Pizza2020 Lakewood Pizza Bake Off
The Buffalo Chicken Pizza


Open Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday
3pm - 9pm

From Papa Nick’s Pizza & Pasta
“Family owned, locally sourced ingredients, everything is homemade, with love from our family to yours.”

Phillip Pamphilis

Pepperoni or Cheese - Slices Always Available!Pizza by the Slice

It’s Hard to Resist a Slice of Papa Nick’s Pie!


Call (216) 281-9191 and order a slice

About Us

Beginning over 40 years ago, this family business has continued to thrive. With each generation, the Papa Nick’s brand evolves and improves. We are proud of our growth and commitment to what we do. We could not have been around all these years without our customers who are equally as dedicated to us as we are to them. From our family to yours, we invite you to come and visit, have a seat and enjoy some good food with family and friends. Come alone or come with others, either way you will never be alone at Papa Nick’s. Bringing families together since 1976.

Papa Nick Pamphilis

Papa Nick’s appreciates you as our customer. Help us reach out to the community by taking a few moments and leave a review on Google for us, we’d be so grateful. #reviewpapanicks